Leah Miller's peaceful life as a member of the Spring Township Amish church shatters when she's accused of theft from an Englisch home in which she works. Even if she is not charged, if the crime is never solved, she will live under the taint of the theft and may never be able to participate fully in her Amish community. Josiah King, friend of Leah's brother, is drawn into helping Leah—and discovers the ‘little sister' he'd always tolerated has grown into a strong, appealing woman.

But what future can they have together if suspicion makes Leah an outcast?  As they attempt to learn the facts behind the accusation, danger grows around them. It's only through their trust in each other and the support of a faithful English friend that Leah and Josiah can find their way through a tangled, dangerous maze to the truth.